Smoked by AI

culture of place

Gelato in Rome.

how it is eaten · Monteverde Nuovo, and a counter on most quarters

The Infatuation's rule for picking a gelateria is a craft test rather than a taste one: good gelato is served warmer than ice cream and melts faster, so a towering display is the warning sign. Marco Radicioni pasteurises six litres at a time at Otaleg and churns in a vertical machine that whips in less air, and Sarah Cicolini's flavour there is rosemary sorbet.

What it is

Cold, dense, and served warmer than ice cream. The Infatuation states its selection rule before it names a single shop, and it is a craft test rather than a taste one: "The best gelato is served at a slightly higher temperature than typical ice cream, leading to a faster melt, so steer clear of places flaunting towering displays, it's a sign that what they're selling may be whipped with air or packed with stabilizers." 1 That single sentence sorts most of the counters in the centre, and it is the one thing to carry around this city.

How it is done

Marco Radicioni moved every machine into one shop on Viale dei Quattro Venti in June 2023 because two labs did not work for somebody who wants to control the gelato right up to the counter. He pasteurises six litres at a time, for every flavour, and churns in a vertical batch freezer he prefers because it whips in less air. 3 Less air is the whole argument the Infatuation's rule is pointing at, arrived at from the maker's side. The house builds recipes by subtraction, with no additives and no surplus sugar. 4 On the plainest thing he makes, Radicioni told Gambero Rosso "when I make the fior di latte I am happy", and the fior di latte changes through the year with the pasture and the hay. 3

Who does it

Antonella De Santis introduces Radicioni as "one of the most important and most awarded gelato makers in Italy". 3 He learned it working for one of the city's first gourmet gelato makers, which The Infatuation reports without naming the shop. 1 Sarah Cicolini sends people to Otaleg (Monteverde) and her reason is the counter turning over: "it stands out for its truly unique and hyper, seasonal flavors. Think prickly pear, passion fruit with cocoa beans, or even gorgonzola with blond chocolate. They also offer an entire section of dairy-free sorbets." 2

On the list

  • best version at

    Otaleg (Monteverde)

    Marco Radicioni moved his whole production into this shop so nothing leaves his hands before it reaches the counter.

    “one of the most important and most awarded gelato makers in Italy”

    Gambero Rosso, Antonella De Santis, 25 May 2023 [3]

Where to get it

Otaleg (Monteverde) in Monteverde Nuovo, and go without a flavour in mind. Cicolini will not name a single favourite for the same reason: "I don't have a single favorite flavor sorbet since the flavors are always changing with the seasons, but I really love their beautifully aromatic rosemary sorbet." 2 The counter opens for breakfast and runs late; the coffee bar inside it shuts in the afternoon while the gelato keeps going. 4 The Trastevere shop on Via di San Cosimato is the same business through a different door, and Katie Parla names eight more gelaterie across the city alongside this one; she sells paid walking tours in Rome. 5

Sources & mentions

  1. [1]
    The Infatuation, The 14 Best Gelato Spots In Rome, Annie Replogle, 11 January 2024, on how to pick one

    “The best gelato is served at a slightly higher temperature than typical ice cream, leading to a faster melt, so steer clear of places flaunting towering displays—it's a sign that what they're selling may be whipped with air or packed with stabilizers.”

    “Otaleg (which, yes, is gelato spelled backwards) was founded by an employee of one of Rome's first gourmet gelato-makers.”

  2. [2]
    Sarah Cicolini, chef-owner of SantoPalato, interviewed by Tyla Shur in The Relisher, 1 April 2025

    “Otaleg (Gelato backwards) is my favorite Gelato shop. It's located in the beautiful Monteverde Nuovo neighbourhood. For me, it stands out for its truly unique and hyper, seasonal flavors. Think prickly pear, passion fruit with cocoa beans, or even gorgonzola with blond chocolate. They also offer an entire section of dairy-free sorbets.”

    “I don't have a single favorite flavor sorbet since the flavors are always changing with the seasons, but I really love their beautifully aromatic rosemary sorbet.”

  3. [3]
    Marco Radicioni, in Gambero Rosso, 25 May 2023, on the fior di latte

    “when I make the fior di latte I am happy”

  4. [4]
  5. [5]